The Truth About Gratitude and Mental Health: Beyond “Good Vibes Only”

As Thanksgiving approaches, we’re surrounded by reminders to “be grateful” and “look on the bright side.” Social media is filled with gratitude challenges, and well-meaning advice often encourages us to focus on what’s good, even when life feels hard. But what if you’re struggling? Is gratitude just about ignoring problems or pretending everything is fine?

At Bien-être Counselling, we believe gratitude is powerful—but only when it’s real, nuanced, and grounded in your actual experience. True gratitude isn’t about “good vibes only.” It’s about finding moments of meaning and hope, even when things aren’t perfect.

Debunking the Myth: Gratitude Isn’t About Ignoring Problems

There’s a common misconception that gratitude means suppressing difficult feelings or denying challenges. In reality, gratitude and struggle can coexist. You can feel anxious, sad, or overwhelmed—and still notice something good in your day. Research shows that acknowledging both hardship and gratitude actually supports better mental health than forced positivity.

Realistic gratitude is honest. It might sound like:

• “I’m having a tough week, but I’m grateful for my friend who checked in.”
• “Today was stressful, and I appreciate the quiet moment I had with my coffee.”
• “I’m grieving, and I’m thankful for the support around me.”

This kind of gratitude doesn’t erase pain—it helps you hold on to hope and resilience alongside it.

The Benefits of Gratitude for Mental Health

Practicing gratitude has been linked to a range of mental health benefits, including:

• Improved mood and emotional balance
• Greater resilience in the face of stress
• Better sleep and physical health
• Stronger relationships and sense of connection

In Ontario and around the world, therapists often encourage gratitude practices—not as a magic fix, but as a tool to gently shift perspective and build emotional resources. Importantly, gratitude works best when it’s authentic, not forced.

How to Practice Realistic Gratitude (Without Faking It)

You don’t need to write a daily list of “10 things you’re grateful for” (unless that genuinely helps you). Instead, try these simple, evidence-based gratitude practices:

1. Notice Small WinsAt the end of each day, ask yourself: “What’s one small thing that went okay today?” It could be a smile from a stranger, a moment of calm, or finishing a task you’ve been putting off.

2. Gratitude Journaling—Your WayKeep a notebook or a note on your phone where you jot down moments of gratitude as they happen. Don’t pressure yourself to write every day—consistency matters more than quantity.

3. Share Thanks Out LoudTell someone you appreciate them, or send a quick message of thanks. Gratitude is contagious—sharing it can boost your mood and strengthen relationships.

4. Pair Gratitude With Self-CompassionIf you’re struggling, it’s okay to acknowledge that and still look for something positive.Example: “This is hard, and I’m grateful for my own effort today.”

5. Practice Mindful AppreciationPause for a moment to notice something pleasant—a warm mug, a cozy blanket, a favorite song. Let yourself feel the comfort it brings, even briefly.

Gratitude as a Tool for Resilience—Not Perfection

At Bien-être Counselling, we see gratitude as one tool among many for supporting mental health. It’s not about ignoring real problems or “fixing” difficult emotions. Instead, gratitude can help you build resilience, find meaning in small moments, and stay connected to what matters—even during challenging times.

If this season feels heavy, remember: you don’t have to feel grateful all the time. Start where you are. Notice what’s real. And know that reaching out for support is always a valid—and courageous—step.

If you’re struggling with gratitude or mental health this Thanksgiving, Bien-être Counselling is here to help. Book a free 20-minute consultation to talk about what you’re facing and how we can support you.

Contact Bien-être Counselling or call (613) 670-6602

#GratitudeAndMentalHealth #BenefitsOfGratitude #GratitudePracticeOntario #RealisticGratitude #ThanksgivingMentalHealth #BienEtreBulletin